Also, here are a few places I've donated to that have replied with Yes, what they gave, and how to contact them. (I don't have a few contacts as I was not the one to get ahold of them. But at least this way you can know they will donate!
)
Walk-in with Letterhead:
George's...................................$25 Gift Card
The Secret Ingredient...............$25 Gift Card
Kids Ink Children's Bookstore...Book + $5 Gift Card
Chik-fil-a....................................Gift Bag
Email official Letter
Handel's Ice Cream..................(2) $10 Gift Card
SunKing Brewery......................Gift Bag ($75 value)
Conner Prairie...........................(4) Admission Pass Ticket
Morty's Comedy.........................(2) Laugh Pack (admits 2 each)
tony@ mortyscomedy.com
Stampin' Up................................Gift Basket ($200 value)
support@ stampinup.com
Rock Auto.................................Gift Certificate, Hat, & T-Shirt
marketing@ rockauto.com; Ashley
Jan Brett.....................................Autographed Poster
janbrett@ janbrett.com
Edible Arrangements (Indy).......Gift Card
Mail Official Letter to Business
Climb Time Indy........................(3) Day Pass + Gear Rental
Online Form
Comedy Sportz.........................(6) Admission Ticket
comedysportzindianapolis.requestitem.com/
Kings Island..............................(2) General Admission Tickets
apps.visitkingsisland.com/public/news/charitable/
Cedar Point...............................(2) General Admission Tickets
apps.cedarpoint.com/public/admission/charitable/index.cfm?
Bob Munsch..............................Autographed Book
robertmunsch.com/contact
Indiana Beach...........................(4) Day Pass
indianabeach.com/pages/ibap_sk_contact_us
Crew (Mike's) Car Wash...........(5) $5 Off Car Wash
www.mikescarwash.com/Contact.aspx
Hope this helps a little! I still have quite a few requests in limbo, so hopefully I'll hear back from them soon and can add more to this list.