Ours is also called "Challenge". We have done it both ways. Last year, the children had a certain time each day when they left their regular class to go to Challenge. This year, we have it so that there is one classroom, if needed, for each grade.
There was a real problem with the first way, because A) it disrupted the homeroom class and what I thought was a bigger problem, it singles out children as different. Yes, it is cool to be smart, but it shouldn't make any other child feel badly. I know that my own son (who tested for the program at the school's request) scored in the 99% for math, 98% for reading and comprehension and "only" 97% for english, which meant that he didn't make it (have to be 98% or better in all 3). So, is he 'gifted'? Yes. Is he gifted enough? Not for our district. Did one of his friends score better? Yes. Is he smarter than my child? Maybe, maybe not, but my child feels that his buddy is smarter and his buddy feels he is smarter and we are just talking one percentile point!
This year, they have the children who scored as "gifted" in separate classrooms. The classrooms are smaller (average 20 children vs 25 children) and it seems to be working out better for our school. The only problem I have with the classrooms is that, as one 'gifted' instructor said, <blockquote>quote:</font><hr> we put all the gifted kids together and then fill it up with the others. <hr></blockquote>. This is because there aren't always 20 gifted per grade per year. Well, I don't want my son listed as or treated as one of "the others".
The only other thing is that this is something the school district does. It is not a PTO sponsored 'thing'. We do not handle Title I or Challenge programs. We treat all classes the same because they all have ALL OF OUR Children in them.
Special Note to SusieQ: I think that Challenge programs are great. I just wish school districts would find a way so that the children who aren't in them don't feel inferior. I find it absolutely amazing that a district as large as yours doesn't have one. Here is an idea: If you have a Title I program, find out how it got approved. My bet is that it was approved because of what it could do for the school and it's tax (and other) dollars. Take a look at different Grant possibilities based on being a Title I AND a Gifted school. You may find that the best way to get something like the Gifted program is to show the district how it looks on their bottom line, ie: SHOW THEM THE MONEY!!!

LOL!
[ 03-30-2002: Message edited by: TheMetzyMom ]</p>