Our most popular items are from Raymond Geddes. The plastic footballs (they look like the old folded paper one) are popular year round. So are the cute erasers (Zoo Life, Sea Life, etc). We sell them for $0.35 each and can't keep them in stock. Any of their highlights (smelly, erasable, etc) are good sellers too.
We learned to stay away from any erasers that break into small pieces as they were either getting lost or driving teachers crazy with kids playing with the all day.
Hi again KNelson,
Totally misread your message. My bad! The only positive is we have a great conversation about holiday shops on Facebook. Getting back to your question, I will put that one out on Facebook as well so we get some good responses for you!
Thank you Leah. That's sort of the idea I had. That way you have new things and not the same stuff all year. What are some of the items you sell? No food.