Fundraising guy here again, most major companies had delivery problems this year so I would not go by one years experience. Of course if the company did not resolve the problem then that is another story. Anywho, they are all National companies with Innisbrook and Sally Foster looking about the same, Cherrydale has some unique products and is under new ownership.
I will check out Jaxco... but I just don't know if I can give up 15% profit to my school just for home delivery. Out Innisbrook delivery always goes easy and quick.
I'd also suggest you take a look at JAXCO. I posted here a few months ago looking for information about them, and was worried because no one really had experience with them. But, the quality of the products was good, delivery was within their contracted 4 week time period, and the error rate was very low. But the best part was that they shipped all the product directly to customer's homes, and the shipments included a JAXCO number to call if there were problems. So, we didn't have to deal with unloading and sorting mountains of boxes, resolving discrepancies on orders, etc. Our rep was pleasant and responsive.
All that said, I still love the quality and designs of Sally Foster paper the best. If my kids ever stop selling Sally Foster, I'll probably hunt down some other kids who do sell it!