Hi milkbrain,
For starters, lots of groups have had struggles with their principals, so you aren't alone. Often, it comes down to communications issues -- both parties (your group and the principal) do not understand where the other is coming from or what the other is trying to do.
It would be really helpful if your board and the principal could get together and have a conversation about what your PTO wants to do and can do for the school. It also would be really helpful if the principal could understand that the purpose of your group is to be an independent group of parents that fosters a sense of community, creates programs to help the kids, supports teachers, and helps get parents involved. The more of a community your group can develop, the better the school community, and the better the kids will do.
So, perhaps this principal doesn't really understand your group's purpose. And, perhaps there is a way to share these ideas in a way that isn't threatening or challenging, but is shared in the spirit of being creating a partnership.
At the same time, your group may not understand what the principal's concerns are about how your group operates and could really benefit to hear that.
The air needs to be cleared before everyone can move forward and it is early enough in the school year to do this and still have a great year.
For help, check out our articles on working with the principal. There are great tips for fixing and building a great working relationship.
Here's the link to our collection of articles:
www.ptotoday.com/the-principal
Hang in there and good luck!
Rose C.
Community Manager