I don't know what state you're in (I'm presuming Ohio)but I don't know if it really matters. If you use their EIN they can pretty much do as they please. If you're separate they can still limit the amount of fundraisers you
do in the school or on school property and if you send them home via backpack express. If you're separate they can't control your activities
off school property
unless you use the school's name in your group's name. The reasoning is that you're using their name and they need to control the image connected with it. We run everything by our BOE just to cover our as$es--but they're pretty good and don't give us much trouble. A lot of school districts put a limit on the number of fundraisers--I wish ours would! Some of the groups are out of control with their nickel and diming everyone to death. Even if you opt not to participate it's aggravating to get them.
They expect your funds to be handled by the state treasurer's office? :confused: How? Like some state worker in the treasury department would want to be your bookkeeper?
I'm thinking they mean they want you to report your income to the state and the IRS at tax time, which you may not HAVE to do depending on how much you make but it's just a prudent thing to do.
I would have the officers arrange a meeting with the superintendent-- not to argue-- but to clarify what exactly they mean. I'd also ask HOW they want you to do what they want you to do. I don't know who governs charitable institution activity in your state (in New Jersey it's the Office of the Attorney General, Division of Consumer Affairs) but I would start there. I would also check with the department that handles incorporation (in NJ it's The Treasury Department, Division of Revenue). I would also check with other PTOs in other school districts, or the state PTA division if you're a PTA.
I'd be interested in how they define "fundraiser;" just because an event or activity might make a small profit a fundraiser it does not make!